Revues of the music of Stephen Sondheim are not exactly a rare thing. We’ve had Side by Side by Sondheim and Marry Me A Little (both of which younger Me wore out the vinyl/CDs of); Putting It Together (ditto, plus endless rewatches of the filmed version with Carol Burnett, George Hearn, Bronson Pinchot, John Barrowman and Ruthie Henshall), Sondheim: A Celebration at Carnegie Hall (okay, this was a one-night thing, but I wore out the CD and the DVD!) and Sondheim on Sondheim (back to “wore out the CD”) – none of which I ever saw on stage.
So as soon as I saw posts online about Sondheim’s Old Friends opening in London, I knew that if it came to Broadway, I’d need to see it; especially if certain members of the London cast transferred. Which they did.
Unlike Marry Me A Little and Putting It Together (each of which has a loose plot and unnamed characters, pulling Sondheim classics and cut/forgotten numbers into a new storyline) but like Side by Side by Sondheim and Sondheim on Sondheim, Sondheim’s Old Friends is a true revue: very little talking except at the very beginning and end, no new storyline, just song after amazing song after brilliant song. Two-and-a-half hours of songs, with only pauses long enough for the audience to applaud (and applaud we did. Loudly.). And several of those songs brought down the house.
The ensemble is led, just as it was in London, by the iconic duo of Bernadette Peters and Lea Salonga. I’ve seen Bernadette several times before and she never disappoints. This was my first time seeing Lea live on stage, and she was as phenomenal as I’ve heard she is. They are backed up by an ensemble of 17, including Beth Leavel, Joanna Riding, Jeremy Secomb (who was out the night we saw the show), Kyle Selig, Bonnie Langford (who I was overjoyed was continuing on from the London cast, as I’ve always wanted to see her on stage), and Gavin Lee (who I last saw as Squidward in The SpongeBob Musical and who is always fun to watch).
Bernadette mentions at the start that the song selection is drawn heavily from shows Cameron Macintosh (who produced this revue) had a hand in. Thus, the show has solid sequences showcasing Into the Woods, Sweeney Todd, West Side Story, and Follies, with a generous helping of Company interspersed, along with bits of Gypsy, Passion, and A Funny Thing Happened On the Way to the Forum. Unlike earlier revues, the show is light on Sondheim’s lesser-known material (nothing from Saturday Night or the Frogs, which usually show up in these revues, for instance) with the exception of “Live Alone and Like It” (performed jauntily by Jason Pennycooke), “The Boy From…” (performed hysterically by Kate Jennings Grant), and a bit of “Bounce” (in a sort-of-medley with “I Know Things Now,” performed with tongue planted firmly in cheek by Bernadette). Past Sondheim revues have been known for weird mashups that work well (I’m thinking of Dorothy Loudon’s “Losing My Mind/You Could Drive A Person Crazy” from the Carnegie Hall concert in particular), and the “Know Things/Bounce” combo worked as well.
Powerhouse moments of the night: Beth Leavel STOPPED. THE. SHOW. with “Ladies Who Lunch.” Lea did the same in Act Two with “Everything’s Coming Up Roses.” Both songs are acerbic and angry, and Beth and Lea let it all out. Bernadette’s renditions of “Send in the Clowns” and “Losing My Mind” had the tears flowing, as did Lea’s “Loving You” (not one of my favorite Sondheim songs, and Lea still managed to make me sob) and “Somewhere,” and all of the women singing “Not A Day Goes By” to a photo of Sondheim. Equally powerful on the comedic side: Lea as Mrs. Lovett alongside Kevin Earley as Sweeney on “Worst Pies in London” and “A Little Priest.”
Personal highlights for me: Bonnie Langford’s take on “I’m Still Here,” Gavin Lee’s “Could I Leave You?” and Gavin and Beth’s “It’s The Little Things You Do Together,” three of my favorite Sondheim songs. Those first two could easily have gone to Bernadette and Lea, who of course would have been phenomenal, but I felt something special seeing one of my favorite Doctor Who companions sing about still being in the game after all these years and seeing Gavin chew the scenery on a song from Follies usually sung by a woman (they used this conceit in Side by Side by Sondheim as well).
If most of the highlights I’ve mentioned featured the female cast members, I have to admit that the show feels more heavily weighted to them both as solo performances and in the group numbers. The women have pretty much all of the true showstoppers. Jacob Dickey does have the lead on “Being Alive,” but it quickly turns into a full-cast number; Kyle Selig shines during the “Tonight Quintet” but I would love to have seen what he would have done solo with “Maria” or “Something’s Coming.” Kyle, Jacob, and Daniel Yearwood harmonize wonderfully on “Waiting For the Girls Upstairs,” and Gavin, Jason, and Kyle are very funny on “Everybody Ought to Have a Maid,” both of which got boisterous applause. I also personally liked Jason’s “Live Alone and Like It,” one of my favorite Sondheim ditties, but let’s be honest: the song doesn’t pack the emotional heft of the songs Bernadette, Lea, and Beth have. It’s possible this sense of imbalance is because there’s no male cast member of the stature of Bernadette and Lea. Or maybe it’s just the way director Matthew Bourne put the show together and chose who would get each number.
I also have to give kudos to “the Sondheim orchestra,” on stage throughout the show, conducted by Annbritt duChateau, and to the set design by Matt Kinley, which made brilliant use of minimal set pieces to move from a classic concert staging to full scenery for the Sweeney and West Side sequences, and to Warren Letton’s lighting design and Jill Parker’s costumes.
Sondheim’s Old Friends runs through mid-June at the Samuel J. Friedman Theatre. It’s well worth the price of admission.
We saw the show during the annual fundraising competition for Broadway Cares. I have no idea who bought Bernadette or Lea’s earrings, offered from the stage. I did spring for a copy of the commemorative program signed by the entire cast.
I’ve always loved live theater, and in the past couple of years I’ve been making a stronger effort to see more of it. Theater Thursday is a new occasional series where I talk about live theater, both shows I’ve seen recently and shows I’ve loved in the past.